Proofpack verification log
Scope
| Field | Record |
|---|---|
| Work item | Incomplete release evidence can look ready |
| Date and owner | 2026-08-31, Codex implementation agent |
| In scope | CLI exit codes, required evidence checks, duplicate checks, hook fixtures, npm package manifest |
| Out of scope | Registry publication, container registry push, remote deployment |
| Runtime | Node.js v24.16.0 on local macOS host; Docker client 29.5.3 |
| Base commit | e4833e5ee51c4a0539c1d55f2a6e22a5b02b929c |
| Source fingerprint | SOURCE-FINGERPRINT.txt, SHA-256 17584d76f561a8f9153fc60c8e2340563de6a716e6fd57706dd1937cf3f3ece6 |
| Worktree state at verification | Review changes staged on codex/learning-project; no unstaged owned files; integration into main not performed or verified |
Executable checks
| Check | Command | Exit status | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Unit and integration tests | npm test | 0 | PASS, 11 of 11 tests |
| Hook fixtures | npm run hook:fixtures | 0 | PASS, 4 of 4 hook tests covering seven inputs |
| Ready candidate | npm run verify | 0 | PASS, ready: true and no problems |
| Package manifest | npm run package:check | 0 | PASS, five files, dry-run SHA-1 488681faf85b86e9b4b8cfb51002ffb1c5d3b3e5 |
| Skill frontmatter | ruby -ryaml parse plus broad Bash grant assertion | 0 | PASS for YAML syntax and scoped Bash entries; skills-ref not run |
| Markdown links | node --test test/documentation-links.test.mjs | 0 | PASS, one of one test |
| Docker build | docker build -t proofpack-learning:local . | not run | UNKNOWN, Docker daemon access denied in this worktree environment |
| Container execution | docker run --rm proofpack-learning:local | not run | UNKNOWN, no verified image |
Test-first record
The CLI acceptance test first failed because src/cli.mjs did not exist. The incomplete, malformed, duplicate, and invalid-version cases then failed against the initial ready-only implementation. The review cycles failed on NOT RUN, no retained output, UNKNOWN, failed, not executed, and unverified before the corresponding evidence sentinel checks existed. The hook tests first failed because the hook did not exist. The Docker push case and the empty-quote variants failed with an allow decision before their deny rules were added. The package negative test accepted invalid JavaScript before node --check joined the package gate.
Final claim
Status: PASS for the local Node.js acceptance contract. Docker build and execution remain UNKNOWN.
The Node.js checks can prove only the listed local behavior on the recorded revision and runtime. Candidate evidence validation is a sentinel screen over an unstructured string; the proof log, not that field, carries command, exit-status, and checksum evidence. package:check validates JavaScript syntax and the npm manifest, but it does not execute the packed CLI. Docker behavior remains UNKNOWN until both Docker commands run successfully.