Quality Document -- Project 06 Capstone
Scoring Summary
| Dimension | Grade | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Build & Compile | C | Builds but has unused import warnings |
| Feature Completeness | D | Missing feedback, clean state, benchmarking |
| ConversationHistory | D | Basic list display, no chat bubbles or interactivity |
| Structured Logging | C | Logger exists but not used in all services |
| Q&A with Citations | B | Works for basic queries |
| Document Import | B | Works via dev console only |
| Indexing | B | Batch indexing works, no progress reporting |
| Persistence | B | Data persists across restarts |
| Test Coverage | F | No tests written |
| Documentation | D | Minimal AGENTS.md only |
| Clean State | F | No reset functionality |
| Benchmarking | F | No benchmark scripts |
Overall Grade: D+
Critical Gaps
- No feedback collection on Q&A responses
- No clean state reset functionality
- No benchmark scripts
- ConversationHistory is a flat list without chat styling
- Logger is basic -- no structured JSON output
- No test coverage at all
- Missing all advanced harness files (CLAUDE.md, feature_list.json, etc.)
Action Items
- [ ] Add FeedbackEntry type and feedback service
- [ ] Implement clean state reset via IPC
- [ ] Create benchmark.sh script
- [ ] Enhance ConversationHistory with chat bubbles
- [ ] Add structured JSON logging to all services
- [ ] Write tests for all services
- [ ] Create full harness (CLAUDE.md, feature_list.json, init.sh, etc.)