Reviewer Rubric
Five dimensions, scored 0 to 2.
- Problem fit — did the change solve the task as stated?
- Scope discipline — were edits confined to the contract?
- Assumptions — are hidden assumptions written down?
- Verification quality — does acceptance actually prove the goal?
- Handoff readiness — can the next session pick up cleanly?
Total >= 7 with no zeros: pass. Total 5-6: soft fail. Below 5 or any zero: hard fail.