Scored Reference Rubric

Reference packet: reference-architecture-packet.md

Area	Weight	Score	Evidence	Remaining work
Solution design	17	16	Three patterns compared; workflow selected with reversal rule	Add measured pilot branch frequency
Models, prompts, context	13	11	Bounded draft, versioning, stable-prefix and validation decisions	Benchmark model routes on golden set
Integration	19	18	Filtered RAG, trusted identity, least privilege, approval design	Run real tenant-isolation integration test
Evaluation and optimization	16	14	Representative slices and hard quality, latency, safety gates	Add confidence intervals and sample minimums
Governance and risk	14	13	Risk, owners, qualified review, material-change triggers	Complete owner approvals
Stakeholder lifecycle	14	13	Executive decision, rollout, runbooks, handoff drills	Conduct receiving-team acceptance drill
Developer operations	7	6	Versioned contracts, traces, rollback, local verification	Add deployment-specific canary automation
Total	100	91	Ready for architecture defense, not production release	Complete live evidence and owner approvals

Hard-gate status:

• Authorization: designed, local contract evidence passes, live integration pending.
• Cross-tenant isolation: required, production integration evidence pending.
• Unsafe action count: zero in the local representative suite.
• Rollback: packet and runbook complete, receiving-team drill pending.

The 91-point score cannot override pending hard-gate evidence. The correct disposition is architecture-defense ready and production-release blocked until the live controls and handoff drill pass.